5369 New York 40, Argyle, NY 12809 (MLS# 202619576)

Original List Price: 199900

List Price/SqFt: 42.58

List Price/Acres: 199900

Status: Active

Current Price: $199,900

List Price: $199,900

Listing Contract Date: 2026-06-12

Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

City/Town (Mail): Argyle

Street Number: 5369

Street Name: New York 40

County: Washington

State/Province: NY

Postal Code: 12809

Geo Lat: 43.26114

Geo Lon: -73.469326

Rooms Total: 13

Bathrooms Half: 1

Garage Spaces: 3

Above Grade Finished Area: 4695

Above Grade Finished Area Source: CRS

Parking Y/N: Yes

Below Grade Finished Area: 0

Below Grade Finished Area Source: CRS

Living Area: 4695

Total Finished Area: 4695

Zoning: Mixed

Lot Size Acres: 1

Waterfront Y/N: No

Enhanced Accessible Y/N: Yes

Bedrooms Total: 6

Bathrooms Full: 1

Bathrooms Total: 2

Year Built: 1900

New Construction Y/N: No

Parcel Number: 173.-2-5

Tax Annual Amount: 3283

Tax Section: 173

Total Taxes Description: Actual

Tax Block: 2

Tax Lot: 5

School District: Argyle

Elementary School: Argyle K-8

High School: Argyle

Association Y/N: No

Directions: GPS 5369 NY 40 Argyle NY 12809

Public Remarks: A rare opportunity to own a truly one-of-a-kind property bursting with character, history, and potential. This former church sits overlooking picturesque countryside and offers a blank canvas for visionaries, entrepreneurs, investors, or anyone looking for an extraordinary place to call home, establish a business, or create a unique work space! While the property requires restoration and TLC, it is currently livable and usable as-is, allowing you to renovate and restore at your own pace. Many of its original features remain intact, including beautiful woodworking details, soaring ceilings, and hardwood floors just waiting to be brought back to life. The stunning foyer welcomes you into an impressive great room, complete with a stage, bar area, and endless possibilities for future use. Currently, four rooms on the main level are being utilized as bedrooms, alongside a storage room. The main floor also features a kitchen and bath making it ideal for redevelopment as a residence, event space, studio, office, retail concept, or mixed-use venture. Upstairs, you'll find a separate apartment offering multiple bedrooms, a kitchen, full bathroom, and living room. Live upstairs while renovating the main level or rent the apartment to help offset renovation costs. Zoned Residential/Commercial, this property offers flexibility rarely found in today's market. Whether your dream is a unique home, creative business space, venue, gallery, café, or something entirely your own, the opportunities here are endless. Adding to its charm, the original church bell still hangs in the tower--a reminder of the building's rich history and timeless presence. If you've been searching for a property with soul, character, and unlimited potential, this is your chance to bring a remarkable piece of history back to life.

Septic Tank: 1

Accessible Approach with Ramp: 1

Accessible Doors: 1

Accessible Hallway(s): 1

Accessible Kitchen: 1

Customized Wheelchair Accessible: 1

Electric Oven: 1

Refrigerator: 1

Custom: 1

General Taxes: 2170.63

General Taxes Description: Actual

School Taxes: 1111.61

School Taxes Description: Actual

Floored: 1

Full: 1

Storage: 1

Unfinished Bonus Room: 1

None: 1

Full: 1

Interior Entry: 1

Unfinished: 1

Full Bath 1: 2nd

Half Bath 1: 1st

Combined DR/LR: 1

Dining Area: 1

Formal Dining Room: 1

Great Room: 1

In Kitchen: 1

Wood Siding: 1

Garage(s): 1

Photo Owner: Combination Ownership

At Closing: 1

None: 1

Carpet: 1

Linoleum: 1

Wood: 1

Key: 1

Occupied: 1

Pet(s) on Premises: 1

Ownership: Belden

Slate: 1

Meadow: 1

Mountain(s): 1

Pasture: 1

Trees/Woods: 1

Well: 1

Stone: 1

Drilled: 1

Pellet Stove: 1

Cathedral Ceiling(s): 1

Parking Total: 15

Circular Driveway: 1

Detached: 1

Driveway: 1

Garage: 1

Off Street: 1

Stone: 1

Workshop in Garage: 1

Covered: 1

Front Porch: 1

Fixer: 1

Full Bathroom: 1

Full Bathroom Level: Second

Half Bathroom: 1

Half Bathroom Level: First

Foyer: 1

Foyer Level: First

Bedroom: 1

Bedroom Level: First

Dining Room: 1

Dining Room Level: Second

Great Room: 1

Great Room Level: First

Kitchen: 1

Kitchen Level: First

Living Room: 1

Living Room Level: Second

Office: 1

Office Level: First

Status Change Date: 2026-06-12