5 Water Street, Warrensburg, NY 12885 (MLS# 202619880)

Original List Price: 229000

List Price/SqFt: 97.16

List Price/Acres: 587179.49

Status: Active

Current Price: $229,000

List Price: $229,000

Listing Contract Date: 2026-06-17

Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

Postal Code +4: 1803

City/Town (Mail): Warrensburg

Cross Street: Main St.

Street Number: 5

Street Name: Water

Street Suffix: Street

County: Warren

State/Province: NY

Postal Code: 12885

Geo Lat: 43.491427

Geo Lon: -73.768747

Rooms Total: 10

Bathrooms Half: 0

Garage Spaces: 1

Above Grade Finished Area: 2357

Above Grade Finished Area Source: Public Records

Parking Y/N: Yes

Below Grade Finished Area: 0

Below Grade Finished Area Source: Public Records

Living Area: 2357

Total Finished Area: 2357

Fireplaces Total: 0

Lot Size Dimensions: 158' x 147' x 72' x 44' x 54' x 58' x 29'

Lot Size Acres: 0.39

Main Road Frontage: 158

Waterfront Y/N: Yes

Water Body Name: Schroon River

Enhanced Accessible Y/N: No

Survey Y/N: Yes

Green Features Y/N: No

Land Lease Y/N: No

Bedrooms Total: 6

Bathrooms Full: 2

Bathrooms Total: 2

Year Built: 1887

New Construction Y/N: No

Parcel Number: 524000 211.13-4-33

Tax Annual Amount: 2889

Tax Section: 211.13

Total Taxes Description: Actual

Tax Block: 4

Tax Lot: 33.000

Tax Section See Remarks: Yes

School District: Warrensburg

Elementary School: Warrensburg

High School: Warrensburg

Association Y/N: No

Directions: I87 to Warrensburg Exit 23. Take a left onto Diamond Point Road and at light bear right onto Route 9 heading north. Take a left onto Water St. and #5 is on the right.

Public Remarks: Cherished for decades, this beloved six-bedroom, two-bathroom home sits in one of Warrensburg's most enviable spots -- directly across the road from the beautiful Schroon River, with lovely porches from which you can take in the water views every single day. A wonderful screened-in porch adds yet another peaceful perch to enjoy the outdoors in comfort. Nestled within Adirondack Park, the location is as practical as it is scenic, with hiking trails, pristine lakes, and four-season recreation all just minutes from your door. Inside, the first floor makes an immediate impression with its stunning walnut woodwork -- rich, warm, and genuinely rare, it lends the home a character that simply cannot be replicated. The flexible six-bedroom layout has been approved by the town for conversion back to a two-family configuration, presenting a compelling opportunity for rental income, a home business, or multi-generational living under one roof. The home has been thoughtfully maintained and many mechanical updates throughout the years. Newer windows bring in natural light while keeping the elements out, and the exterior walls have been insulated with foam for energy efficiency in every season. The electrical system has been upgraded electrical service, a newer boiler was installed in 2015, and -- notably -- the main sewer line to the home was fully replaced in 2025, providing real peace of mind for any buyer. Both public water and public sewer service the property, keeping ongoing maintenance simple and predictable. A detached one-car garage completes the package. This is a rare chance to own a piece of true Adirondack heritage -- a home full of history, character, and comfort, in a setting that people dream about. Agent related to sellers.

Public Sewer: 1

Oil Water Heater: 1

Old Style: 1

100 Amp Service: 1

Tax Assessed Value: 2889

General Taxes: 1644

General Taxes Description: Actual

School Taxes: 1245

School Taxes Description: Actual

None: 1

None: 1

Full Bath 1: 1st

Full Bath 2: 2nd

Formal Dining Room: 1

Road Frontage: 1

Views: 1

Stone: 1

Vinyl Siding: 1

Garage(s): 1

Shed(s): 1

Storage: 1

Photo Owner: Photographer

Other: 1

Living Room: 1

Lockbox: 1

Sign on Property: 1

Standard: 1

Garden: 1

River: 1

Public: 1

Stone: 1

Lake/River Across Rd: 1

Hot Water: 1

Kerosene: 1

Oil: 1

Parking Total: 5

Driveway: 1

Garage: 1

Porch: 1

Screened: 1

Side Porch: 1

Full Bathroom: 1

Full Bathroom Level: Second

Bedroom: 1

Bedroom Level: First

Other Room: 1

Other Room Level: Second

Dining Room: 1

Dining Room Level: First

Kitchen: 1

Kitchen Level: First

Living Room: 1

Living Room Level: First

Status Change Date: 2026-06-17