453 State Highway 334, Johnstown, NY 12095 (MLS# 202616642)


$290,000
453 State Highway 334
Johnstown, NY 12095
MLS# 202616642
8 beds


Currently known as Wemple and Edicks
  1 / 56  
Currently known as Wemple and Edicks w4 w2 Wemple and Edicks w34 Built in shelves w3 w5 Serving counter w7 w9 w10 w11 Kitchen area w14 w15 w16 w17 w18 w19 w20 Front porch 1/2 bath Apartment upstairs w22 w23 w24 w25 w26 w27 w28 w29 w31 w32 w33 Barn in back w46 w51 w52 w49 w48 w50 w54 w55 w47 w53 Property across the street also included in the sale w40 House next door to the store also included in the sale w42 w45 Parcel across the street included in the sale. Extra parking area Wemple and Edicks-64 w38 w57 w57

Property Description
This unique and well-known property, historically recognized as Wemple & Edick's, has long been cherished for its exceptional homemade ice cream, baked goods, and seasonal craft fairs featuring live music and local vendors. Ideally located just minutes from the Historic, city of Johnstown, NY and the NYS Thruway, this offering presents a rare opportunity to carry on a beloved, nostalgic business with an established reputation and loyal following. The property is being offered as a multi-parcel investment, inclusive of four parcels in total. The main building features the retail space along with a second-floor two-bedroom apartment, providing the option to live onsite, generate rental income, or both. Additional structures on the property include a separate house next door with 3 bedrooms, 1 bath and a third building currently in rough condition, which could be removed to create ample additional parking or reimagined for future use-with 3 bedrooms, 1 bath-further expanding the property's versatility and income potential. Another wonderful feature of the property is the historic barn, formerly used as a cider mill, with original equipment still in place, adding character and a true sense of history. The barn is complemented by an inviting outdoor area, perfect for fires, gatherings, and relaxed seating, creating an ideal setting for events or seasonal use. A separate parcel offers ample additional parking along the creek side, creating a beautiful and relaxing setting for customers to enjoy ice cream and gather outdoors. With vision, updates, and care, this property offers exceptional potential for an entrepreneur, investor, or business owner seeking a live/work opportunity. Whether continuing its legacy or creating something new, the possibilities here are truly endless.

Details
Maps
Documents
Contract Information
Original List Price: 310000
List Price/SqFt: 43.75
Status: Active
Property Sub Type: Triplex
List Price: $290,000
Current Price: $290,000
Listing Contract Date: 2026-05-05
Location
City/Town (Mail): Johnstown
Street Number: 453
Street Name: State Highway 334
County: Fulton
State/Province: NY
Postal Code: 12095
Geo Lat: 42.988288
Geo Lon: -74.432079
Property Detail
Rooms Total: 20
Bathrooms Half: 1
Garage Spaces: 2
Above Grade Finished Area: 6628
Above Grade Finished Area Source: CRS
Parking Y/N: Yes
Below Grade Finished Area: 0
Below Grade Finished Area Source: See Remarks
Living Area: 6628
Zoning: Commercial
Lot Size Dimensions: 133x95, 96x83, 40x185, 95x64
Lot Size Acres: 1.35
Waterfront Y/N: No
Enhanced Accessible Y/N: No
Bedrooms Total: 8
Bathrooms Full: 3
Year Built: 1897
Parcel, Tax, HOA
Parcel Number: 173.18-3-6
Tax Annual Amount: 3240
Tax Section: 173.18
Total Taxes Description: Estimated
Tax Block: 3
Tax Lot: 6 plus
School District: Johnstown
Association Y/N: No
Directions & Remarks
Directions: From Johnstown Head toward E State St  Continue to follow NY-67 W  2.0 mi Slight left onto NY-334 S  Destination will be on the left  1.7 mi
Public Remarks: This unique and well-known property, historically recognized as Wemple & Edick's, has long been cherished for its exceptional homemade ice cream, baked goods, and seasonal craft fairs featuring live music and local vendors. Ideally located just minutes from the Historic, city of Johnstown, NY and the NYS Thruway, this offering presents a rare opportunity to carry on a beloved, nostalgic business with an established reputation and loyal following. The property is being offered as a multi-parcel investment, inclusive of four parcels in total. The main building features the retail space along with a second-floor two-bedroom apartment, providing the option to live onsite, generate rental income, or both. Additional structures on the property include a separate house next door with 3 bedrooms, 1 bath and a third building currently in rough condition, which could be removed to create ample additional parking or reimagined for future use-with 3 bedrooms, 1 bath-further expanding the property's versatility and income potential. Another wonderful feature of the property is the historic barn, formerly used as a cider mill, with original equipment still in place, adding character and a true sense of history. The barn is complemented by an inviting outdoor area, perfect for fires, gatherings, and relaxed seating, creating an ideal setting for events or seasonal use. A separate parcel offers ample additional parking along the creek side, creating a beautiful and relaxing setting for customers to enjoy ice cream and gather outdoors. With vision, updates, and care, this property offers exceptional potential for an entrepreneur, investor, or business owner seeking a live/work opportunity. Whether continuing its legacy or creating something new, the possibilities here are truly endless.
Sewer
Septic Tank: 1
Architectural Style
Traditional: 1
Cooling
Wall Unit(s): 1
Basement
Full: 1
Interior Entry: 1
Unfinished: 1
Walk-Out Access: 1
Bath Levels
Full Bath 1: 2nd
Full Bath 2: 1st
Full Bath 3: 1st
Half Bath 1: 1st
Lot Features
Cleared: 1
Road Frontage: 1
Construction Materials
Wood Siding: 1
Other Structures
Barn(s): 1
Second Residence: 1
Photos - the contractual owner of the photos
Photo Owner: Broker
Possession
At Closing: 1
Exterior Features
Other: 1
Flooring
Wood: 1
Showing Requirements
24 Hour Notice: 1
Lockbox: 1
Occupied: 1
Pet(s) on Premises: 1
Special Listing Conditions
Standard: 1
Roof
Metal: 1
Water Source
Well: 1
Waterfront Features
Creek: 1
Heating
Other: 1
Interior Features
Built-in Features: 1
Parking Features
Parking Total: 12
Attached: 1
Detached: 1
Off Street: 1
Patio And Porch Features
Porch: 1
Separate Utilities
Electric: 1
Heat: 1
Multi-Family Unit 1 Detail
Unit Location MF Unit 1: Upstairs
Total Rooms MF Unit 1: 6
Total Bedrooms MF Unit 1: 2
Total Full Baths MF Unit 1: 1
Unit 1 Detail
Total Bedrooms: 2
Multi-Family Unit 2 Detail
Unit Location MF Unit 2: Nextdoor
Total Rooms MF Unit 2: 5
Total Bedrooms MF Unit 2: 3
Total Full Baths MF Unit 2: 1
Unit 2 Detail
Total Bedrooms: 3
Multi-Family Unit 3 Detail
Unit Location MF Unit 3: across
Total Rooms MF Unit 3: 5
Total Bedrooms MF Unit 3: 3
Total Full Baths MF Unit 3: 1
Unit 3 Detail
Total Bedrooms: 3
Status Change Info
Status Change Date: 2026-05-07
Property Features
Architectural Style: Traditional
Basement: Full; Interior Entry; Unfinished; Walk-Out Access
Construction Materials: Wood Siding
Cooling: Wall Unit(s)
Exterior Features: Other
Flooring: Wood
Heating: Other
Interior Features: Built-in Features
Lot Features: Cleared; Road Frontage
Other Structures: Barn(s); Second Residence
Parking Features: Attached; Detached; Off Street
Patio And Porch Features: Porch
Possession: At Closing
Roof: Metal
Separate Utilities: Electric; Heat
Sewer: Septic Tank
Showing Requirements: 24 Hour Notice; Lockbox; Occupied; Pet(s) on Premises
Special Listing Conditions: Standard
Water Source: Well
Waterfront Features: Creek

IDX
Listing Courtesy of Howard Hanna Capital Inc
Listing Agent: Christine A Gerber
518-848-7425 | christinegerber@howardhanna.com
Source MLS Verified

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.