189 Main Street, Cherry Valley, NY 13320 (MLS# 202624015)


$124,900
189 Main Street
Cherry Valley, NY 13320
MLS# 202624015
3 baths  |  2920 sqft


1-189MainSt_01
  1 / 40  
1-189MainSt_01 2-189MainSt_02 3-189MainSt_03 5-189MainSt_05 6-189MainSt_06 7-189MainSt_07 8-189MainSt_08 9-189MainSt_09 10-189MainSt_10 11-189MainSt_11 12-189MainSt_12 13-189MainSt_13 14-189MainSt_14 15-189MainSt_15 16-189MainSt_16 17-189MainSt_17 18-189MainSt_18 19-189MainSt_19 20-189MainSt_20 22-189MainSt_22 23-189MainSt_23 24-189MainSt_24 26-189MainSt_26 27-189MainSt_27 28-189MainSt_28 29-189MainSt_29 30-189MainSt_30 31-189MainSt_31 32-189MainSt_32 34-189MainSt_34 35-189MainSt_35 36-189MainSt_36 40-189MainSt_40 38-189MainSt_38 39-189MainSt_39 41-189MainSt_41 42-189MainSt_42 2-Floorplan_1 1-Floorplan_2 20250808121449_00001

Property Description
Endless opportunity in this 2,920 sqft commercial property, currently a tavern, on a .66-acre corner lot with private parking and municipal water. The two-story building offers versatile space and endless potential. The main level features seating for 70, a stunning classic bar, and fully equipped kitchen. Upstairs offers two bedrooms, full bath--perfect potential owner's residence or rental income. With its vibrant structure and adaptable layout, this building offers limitless potential for many uses. Located in a charming, culturally rich village of Cherry Valley--known for natural beauty, historic heritage, and vibrant arts scene--this property is surrounded by year-round events, shops, and a welcoming community. A short drive to Cooperstown's Dream Park, Opera, and Baseball Hall of Fame.

Details
Maps
Documents
Contract Information
Status: Active
Property Sub Type: Business
Original List Price: 124900
List Price: $124,900
Listing Contract Date: 2026-08-12
Current Price: $124,900
List Price/SqFt: 42.77
List Price/Acres: 189242.42
Location
Street Number: 189
Street Name: Main
Street Suffix: Street
County: Otsego
State/Province: NY
Postal Code: 13320
City/Town (Mail): Cherry Valley
Geo Lat: 42.80016
Geo Lon: -74.742956
Property Detail
Year Built: 1950
Stories: 2
Number Of Buildings: 1
Bathrooms Total: 3
Lot Size Square Feet: 28750
Zoning: Commercial
Lot Size Dimensions: 320FF
Lot Size Acres: 0.66
Building Area Total: 2920
Building Available SQFT: 2900
Main Road Frontage: 600
Waterfront Y/N: No
Financial Details
General Taxes: 2536
General Taxes Description: Actual
School Taxes: 2164
School Taxes Description: Actual
Village Taxes: 1499
Village Taxes Description: Actual
Building Detail
Building Ceiling Height: 8
Office Available SQFT: 2900
Office Ceiling Height: 8
Retail Available SQFT: 2900
Retail Ceiling Height: 8
Photos - the contractual owner of the photos
Photo Owner: Photographer
Parking Features
Parking Total: 25
Status Change Info
Status Change Date: 2026-08-14
Property Features
Architectural Style: Apartments; Bar/Tavern/Lounge; Restaurant; Retail
Basement: Crawl Space
Construction Materials: Wood Siding
Cooling: None
Current Use: Business; Restaurant; Tavern; Tavern Plus
Business Type: Restaurant
Electric: 200+ Amp Service
Flooring: Laminate; Parquet; Wood
Heating: Forced Air; Oil; Pellet Stove
Interior Features: High Speed Internet
Lot Features: Corner Lot; Level; Road Frontage
Parking Features: Gravel; Private
Patio And Porch Features: Porch
Possible Use: Apartment Plus; Business; Restaurant; Tavern; Tavern Plus
Roof: Asphalt; Shingle
Sale Includes: Building & Land; Business & Building
Sewer: Septic Tank
Showing Requirements: Showing Service; Sign on Property
Special Listing Conditions: Standard
Water Source: Public

IDX
Listing Courtesy of Country Boy Realty
Listing Agent: Matthew Loder
518-378-1235 | MLoderCBR@gmail.com
Source MLS Verified

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.