186 Bay 35th Street, Brooklyn, NY 11215 (MLS# 202616966)


$1,899,000
186 Bay 35th Street
Brooklyn, NY 11215
MLS# 202616966
Status: Pending
7 beds


Screen Shot 2026-05-11 at 2.06.08 PM
  1 / 8  
Screen Shot 2026-05-11 at 2.06.08 PM IMG_2450 IMG_2456 IMG_2454 IMG_2452 IMG_2445 IMG_2447 IMG_2459

Property Description
Located in the heart of Brooklyn's desirable Bensonhurst/Bath Beach area, this well-maintained 4-family property offers a prime investment opportunity surrounded by local shops, restaurants, cafés, parks, and everyday conveniences. **No leases** This property offers spacious apartments with eat in kitchens. Shared driveway. Full finished basement. Easy access to public transportation. Downtown Manhattan is approximately 25 minutes away and Midtown about 40 minutes, making this an ideal location for both convenience and connectivity. A perfect blend of neighborhood charm, strong rental appeal, and classic Brooklyn living.

Details
Maps
Documents
Contract Information
Original List Price: 1899000
List Price/SqFt: 624.67
Status: Pending
Property Sub Type: Quadruplex
List Price: $1,899,000
Current Price: $1,899,000
Listing Contract Date: 2026-05-11
Location
City/Town (Mail): Brooklyn
Street Number: 186
Street Name: Bay 35th
Street Suffix: Street
County: Kings
State/Province: NY
Postal Code: 11215
Geo Lat: 40.596064
Geo Lon: -73.994253
Property Detail
Rooms Total: 15
Bathrooms Half: 0
Garage Spaces: 0
Above Grade Finished Area: 3040
Above Grade Finished Area Source: Public Records
Parking Y/N: Yes
Below Grade Finished Area: 0
Below Grade Finished Area Source: See Remarks
Living Area: 3040
Lot Size Acres: 0.04
Waterfront Y/N: No
Enhanced Accessible Y/N: No
Bedrooms Total: 7
Bathrooms Full: 4
Year Built: 1925
Status Change Info
Proposed Closing Date: 2026-09-01
Status Change Date: 2026-05-27
Under Contract Date: 2026-05-25
Parcel, Tax, HOA
Parcel Number: 06889-0047
Tax Annual Amount: 12524
Total Taxes Description: Estimated
School District: Nyc Geog Dist #20 - Brooklyn
Association Y/N: No
Directions & Remarks
Directions: Cropsey Avenue onto Bay 35th St.
Public Remarks: Located in the heart of Brooklyn's desirable Bensonhurst/Bath Beach area, this well-maintained 4-family property offers a prime investment opportunity surrounded by local shops, restaurants, cafés, parks, and everyday conveniences. **No leases** This property offers spacious apartments with eat in kitchens. Shared driveway. Full finished basement. Easy access to public transportation. Downtown Manhattan is approximately 25 minutes away and Midtown about 40 minutes, making this an ideal location for both convenience and connectivity. A perfect blend of neighborhood charm, strong rental appeal, and classic Brooklyn living.
Sewer
Public Sewer: 1
Architectural Style
Other: 1
Financial Details
General Taxes: 12524
General Taxes Description: Estimated
Cooling
Window Unit(s): 1
Basement
Finished: 1
Full: 1
Bath Levels
Full Bath 1: 1st
Full Bath 2: 1st
Full Bath 3: 2nd
Full Bath 4: 2nd
Construction Materials
Brick: 1
Photos - the contractual owner of the photos
Photo Owner: Broker
Possession
At Closing: 1
Exterior Features
Other: 1
Flooring
Hardwood: 1
Tile: 1
Showing Requirements
24 Hour Notice: 1
Call Listing Agent: 1
Special Listing Conditions
Standard: 1
Roof
Rubber: 1
Water Source
Public: 1
Heating
Hot Water: 1
Radiant: 1
Parking Features
Parking Total: 2
Driveway: 1
Levels
Two: 1
Separate Utilities
Electric: 1
Gas: 1
Tenant Pays
Electricity: 1
Gas: 1
Multi-Family Unit 1 Detail
Unit Location MF Unit 1: First
Total Rooms MF Unit 1: 3
Total Bedrooms MF Unit 1: 1
Total Full Baths MF Unit 1: 1
Unit 1 Detail
Total Bedrooms: 1
Multi-Family Unit 2 Detail
Unit Location MF Unit 2: First
Total Rooms MF Unit 2: 4
Total Bedrooms MF Unit 2: 2
Total Full Baths MF Unit 2: 1
Unit 2 Detail
Total Bedrooms: 2
Multi-Family Unit 3 Detail
Unit Location MF Unit 3: Second
Total Rooms MF Unit 3: 4
Total Bedrooms MF Unit 3: 2
Total Full Baths MF Unit 3: 1
Unit 3 Detail
Total Bedrooms: 2
Multi-Family Unit 4 Detail
Unit Location MF Unit 4: Second
Total Rooms MF Unit 4: 4
Total Bedrooms MF Unit 4: 2
Total Full Baths MF Unit 4: 1
Unit 4 Detail
Total Bedrooms: 2
Property Features
Architectural Style: Other
Basement: Finished; Full
Construction Materials: Brick
Cooling: Window Unit(s)
Exterior Features: Other
Flooring: Hardwood; Tile
Heating: Hot Water; Radiant
Levels: Two
Parking Features: Driveway
Possession: At Closing
Roof: Rubber
Separate Utilities: Electric; Gas
Sewer: Public Sewer
Showing Requirements: 24 Hour Notice; Call Listing Agent
Special Listing Conditions: Standard
Tenant Pays: Electricity; Gas
Water Source: Public

IDX
Listing Courtesy of McDonald Real Estate Comp LLC
Listing Agent: Nathaniel Sorce
518-337-1735 | nsorce22@gmail.com

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.