130 Lustig Road, Hunter, NY 12442 (MLS# 202619119)

Original List Price: 1150000

List Price/SqFt: 416.21

List Price/Acres: 244680.85

Status: Active

Current Price: $1,150,000

List Price: $1,150,000

Listing Contract Date: 2026-06-08

Property Sub Type: Single Family Residence

City/Town (Mail): Hunter

Street Number: 130

Street Name: Lustig

Street Suffix: Road

County: Greene

State/Province: NY

Postal Code: 12442

Geo Lat: 42.200192

Geo Lon: -74.186549

Rooms Total: 9

Bathrooms Half: 0

Garage Spaces: 0

Above Grade Finished Area: 2763

Above Grade Finished Area Source: CRS

Parking Y/N: Yes

Below Grade Finished Area: 0

Below Grade Finished Area Source: CRS

Living Area: 2763

Total Finished Area: 2763

Fireplaces Total: 0

Lot Size Acres: 4.7

Waterfront Y/N: No

Enhanced Accessible Y/N: No

Bedrooms Total: 5

Bathrooms Full: 2

Bathrooms Total: 2

Year Built: 1860

New Construction Y/N: No

Parcel Number: 193689 164.00-2-11.11

Tax Annual Amount: 4151.95

Tax Section: 164.00

Total Taxes Description: Actual

Tax Block: 2

Tax Lot: 11.110

School District: Hunter-Tannersville

Association Y/N: No

Directions: Start in the Village of Hunter. Head west on NY-23A. Turn right onto Lustig Road. Continue to 130 Lustig Road.

Public Remarks: Welcome to the ''Hylan House'' at 130 Lustig Road - A beautifully restored 5 Acre Catskills retreat blending historic charm with modern luxury. The childhood home of NYC Mayor John Hylan and once home to songwriter Kermit Goell. This spacious 5-bedroom, 2-bath home has been thoughtfully updated while preserving the character that makes properties like this so special. Recent improvements include a stunning new kitchen, private sauna, outdoor hot tub, Tesla solar panel system, and Tesla EV charging station, creating a turnkey property designed for both comfortable living and exceptional guest experiences. The home's generous layout includes provides ample space for entertaining, weekend gatherings, or a thriving short-term rental investment. Set in the heart of Hunter, this property places you just minutes from Hunter Mountain, hiking trails, restaurants, and year-round Catskill attractions. Whether you're seeking a full-time residence, vacation home, or investment property, 130 Lustig Road delivers the perfect combination of history, modern amenities, and mountain lifestyle. Tesla solar panels offset utility bill to next to nothing! A rare opportunity to own a piece of the Catskills with upgrades already in place and ready to enjoy.

Septic Tank: 1

Gas Cooktop: 1

Gas Oven: 1

Microwave: 1

Farmhouse: 1

200+ Amp Service: 1

None: 1

Partial: 1

Unfinished: 1

Full Bath 1: 1st

Full Bath 2: 2nd

Formal Dining Room: 1

Landscaped: 1

Mountain(s): 1

Views: 1

Wood Siding: 1

Photo Owner: Broker

None: 1

Electric: 1

Full Bathroom: 1

Insert: 1

Living Room: 1

Wood Burning: 1

Carpet: 1

Hardwood: 1

Tile: 1

24 Hour Notice: 1

SeniorCommunity Y/N: No

Asphalt: 1

Shingle: 1

Creek/Stream: 1

Mountain(s): 1

Trees/Woods: 1

Well: 1

Stone: 1

Drilled: 1

Baseboard: 1

Hot Water: 1

Stone Countertops: 1

Built-in Features: 1

Eat-in Kitchen: 1

Modern Kitchen: 1

Laundry Closet: 1

Main Level: 1

Parking Total: 4

Driveway: 1

Front Porch: 1

Spa Y/N: Yes

Bi-Level: 1

Full Bathroom: 1

Full Bathroom Level: First

Bedroom: 1

Bedroom Level: First

Dining Room: 1

Dining Room Level: First

Family Room: 1

Family Room Level: First

Kitchen: 1

Kitchen Level: First

Living Room: 1

Living Room Level: First

Mud Room: 1

Mud Room Level: First

Status Change Date: 2026-06-08